Approximately 500 Ballots Found Near Dumpster at Renton Strip Mall
A Renton resident discovered a box containing approximately 500 blank ballots near a dumpster at a strip mall in February 2025, according to State Representative Jim Walsh, who posted a video about the discovery on social media on April 16. The ballots spanned five years of elections, from 2020 through 2025. The discovery triggered a federal investigation involving the U.S. Postal Inspection Service and FBI. The incident has raised questions about Washington's vote-by-mail infrastructure, specifically regarding ballots that are delivered but never retrieved by voters.
Ballot Tracking and Verification Systems
King County Elections sends more than 1.4 million ballots each election cycle to addresses on file, according to Julie Wise, King County's Director of Elections. Once a ballot is returned, the system tracks it through the counting process. Signatures must match voter registration records before counting, and if multiple ballots are issued to a single voter, only one can be accepted. According to Wise, the verification controls in place would prevent counted ballots from the Renton discovery from being fraudulently processed.
According to Walsh's account, initial findings from investigators indicate the ballots were outgoing, unvoted ballots delivered to a private mailbox location and never picked up by voters. The system includes mechanisms to reject duplicate or forged ballots. However, the system does not track ballots after delivery if they are not returned.
Ballots may accumulate when voters move, abandon private mailboxes, or do not retrieve mail at addresses where they no longer live. Ballots arrive at these addresses and may remain unclaimed for extended periods.
Reporting and Response
The person who found the ballots brought them to Walsh. According to Walsh, the finder stated he attempted to report the ballots to multiple agencies. King County Elections stated it has no record of being contacted about the ballots prior to Walsh's social media post. The Secretary of State's Office stated it has no record of the ballots being reported to them either.
Secretary of State Steve Hobbs stated that people who find undelivered ballots should return them to the sender or turn them over to law enforcement when requested. Federal authorities now have custody of the ballots. King County Elections has not received them for review.
The incident reveals a gap in protocol: no single entity is designated to address the question of what happens to ballots after delivery but before retrieval. The system includes clear protocols for individual incidents, but lacks infrastructure to address patterns of undelivered or unclaimed ballots.
Ballot Replacement and Voter Notification
Walsh described the situation as involving a "broken chain of custody." Voters who do not receive a ballot can request a replacement through King County Elections' website or by calling their voter hotline. The replacement process requires voters to verify their identity and current address, after which a new ballot is issued and the original is flagged as void in the system.
This safeguard requires voters to be aware that their ballot is missing. A voter who moved may assume their ballot will be forwarded, or may not have updated their address with elections officials. The ballot may be delivered to a previous address, a private mailbox facility no longer in use, or an apartment complex mail room. If the voter does not receive the ballot at their current address, they may or may not request a replacement before the deadline.
According to Walsh's examination, the ballots found in Renton show significant numbers from 2022 onward, suggesting accumulation increased in recent election cycles. This timeline corresponds with the period when vote-by-mail became the default method for more Washington voters.
Return Rates and Unaccounted Ballots
King County processes 1.4 million ballots per cycle, with return rates typically exceeding 80 percent in general elections, according to county data. This means approximately 280,000 ballots sent out do not return each cycle in King County. These unreturned ballots represent voters who chose not to vote, voters who voted in person instead, voters who moved and updated their registration elsewhere, voters who never received their ballot, or voters who received it at an address they no longer monitor.
The system does not distinguish between these categories. Both a voter who chose not to participate and a voter who was unable to retrieve their ballot appear the same in the data: an unreturned ballot.
When a voter registers or updates their address, that information enters the statewide voter registration database managed by the Secretary of State's office. County elections offices generate mailing lists approximately three weeks before each election using this database. Ballots are printed, placed in envelopes with prepaid postage, and handed to the U.S. Postal Service for delivery. At that point, direct county control ends. If the Postal Service delivers to an address where the voter no longer lives, the ballot enters a gray zone. Private mailbox facilities are required to return undeliverable mail to sender, but enforcement varies, and the volume of election mail can overwhelm small operations.
According to statements from the King County Prosecuting Attorney's Office, that office will assist investigators in determining how these specific 500 ballots ended up near a dumpster. The investigation may provide information about this particular private mailbox location but will not address the broader question of how many other locations may contain unclaimed ballots from voters unaware their ballots were not delivered.
System Design and Limitations
Washington's vote-by-mail system includes signature matching, one-ballot-per-voter tracking, and voter contact when discrepancies appear. According to election officials, these measures prevent the counting of fraudulent votes.
The system does not include infrastructure to track ballots delivered but never retrieved, to identify voters whose ballots are in limbo, or to ensure voters are aware when their ballots have not been delivered. Private mailbox facilities, apartment complexes, and mail forwarding services operate outside the elections system's visibility. Once a ballot enters these spaces, the county loses tracking ability.
Addressing this gap would require coordination between multiple agencies that currently operate independently. The Secretary of State's office sets statewide election policy and maintains the voter database, while individual counties control ballot printing and mailing. The Postal Service handles delivery but has no obligation to report delivery failures to elections offices. Private mailbox facilities operate under Postal Service regulations but are not integrated into election tracking systems. Any solution would require state legislative action to mandate reporting requirements, funding for tracking infrastructure, and cooperation from the Postal Service, a federal agency outside state control.
The 500 ballots now in federal custody represent ballots accumulated over five years. They represent ballots delivered to addresses where voters no longer retrieve mail. The discovery has made visible a gap in the system between ballot delivery and voter retrieval. The extent of similar situations that remain undetected is unknown.
```